Geico vs. Progressive Review Auto Insurance in 2025 (Side-by-Side Review)

When you compare Geico vs. Progressive auto insurance, you’ll find Geico’s starting rate of $43 per month is cheaper than Progressive’s $56.

Geico might be a bit cheaper, but Progressive offers more coverage options and better digital tools.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rating

However, the best company for you depends on several factors. For example, Geico offers the best auto insurance for federal employees.

Read on to see if Geico or Progressive is right for you. Then, enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool to see which company has the best rates for you.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates

Although many factors affect auto insurance rates, both Geico and Progressive are known for their affordable prices. However, Geico tends to be a bit cheaper than Progressive in most states.

You can explore more specific averages below, but you can get an idea of how much you might spend with Geico and Progressive below.

Geico vs. Progressive Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates

When you compare Progressive vs. Geico, you’ll see that Geico has cheaper rates for every age group. However, Geico isn’t always the cheapest option for every driver. Continue reading to compare Progressive vs. Geico auto insurance rates based on factors like where you live and what your driving record looks like.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates by State

It’s simple — where you live can have a tremendous impact on what you pay in premiums. When looking at rates from state to state, several factors come into play.

In a head-to-head comparison, who has the cheapest rates? Is Geico cheaper than Progressive? Here’s a breakdown of average rates by state:

Geico vs. Progressive Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by State

In reviewing these figures, here’s what we quickly discovered — when it comes to the lowest overall rates, Geico takes a clear lead over Progressive.

So, why are rates so different across the country? Many factors impact your insurance rates, but the main things providers look at are traffic rates, accidents, vehicle crime rates, and how many claims are filed in your ZIP code.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates by Driving Record

Car accidents, speeding tickets, and driving under the influence. They’re all serious infractions that can wreak havoc on your car insurance rates, causing them to increase overnight. Why? Because at the end of the day, car insurance is largely a matter of risk.

 As drivers continue to rack up tickets and violations, insurers will consider them to be higher risks and charge them higher rates.

What’s worse is that as long as these infractions remain on your driving record, these rate hikes can stick with you for years.

Of course, the big question is this — when comparing Geico vs. Progressive, who has the lowest rates for drivers with speeding tickets, accidents, or DUIs? Take a look below to compare rates based on your driving record.

Geico vs. Progressive Full Coverage Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Driving Record

We found that Geico has the lowest average rates for car accidents and speeding tickets, but Progressive’s rates are lower for DUIs.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates After a Speeding Ticket

Speeding tickets are among the most common traffic violations American drivers receive. Although speeding is usually relatively harmless, driving too fast is a common factor in fatal accidents. For this reason, insurance companies charge drivers more when they have speeding tickets on their records.

Compare Progressive auto insurance vs. Geico quotes for drivers with a speeding ticket below.

Geico vs Progressive Auto Monthly Full Coverage Rates by Driving Record

We can clearly see that drivers who are insured with Progressive and have one speeding ticket are paying, on average, $1,356.85 or 33.9% more in rates than those with Geico.

Keep in mind that the surcharge insurers decide to tack on to your annual car insurance premium can vary depending on the nature of your ticket. For instance, someone ticketed for going 10 miles over the speed limit may face a lower increase than a driver ticketed for going 25 miles over the speed limit.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates After At-Fault Accidents

Having a car accident on your record, particularly if you were found at fault, can also have a tremendous bearing on your bottom line. In terms of annual car insurance rates, we can once more see a significant difference between Geico and Progressive.

Geico vs. Progressive: Monthly Full Coverage Auto Insurance Rates by Accident History

When it comes to Progressive versus Geico rates after an accident, Geico is the cheaper option on average. How long auto accidents stay on your driving record depends on where you live, but they usually last about three years. You’ll see higher rates until any accidents you’ve caused drop off your record.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates After a DUI

Without a doubt, the impact of having a DUI conviction on your driving record is severe.

A DUI will not only remain on your record for several years, but it will also cause your car insurance rates to skyrocket.

If your insurer is willing to keep you as a customer, you can be certain that your annual car insurance rates will go up exponentially, as you are now considered a high-risk driver. In this instance, Progressive has the lower figures.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance: Monthly Full Coverage Rates With a DUI

Although Geico is usually cheaper, you’ll see Progressive has lower average rates when you compare Geico vs. Progressive car insurance. This is why it’s so important to compare rates with as many companies as possible — you never know which company will have the cheapest auto insurance after a DUI without checking.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates by Credit Score

The state of your credit matters and can have a lasting impact on your major purchases in most states. That includes buying a home, qualifying for a loan, and even purchasing car insurance.

As providers set rates, they will often look to what is called your credit-based score, or insurance score.  Although this is not the same as your credit score, it’s largely based on your credit history, which includes the following factors:

• Your payment history
• Total debt
• The length of your credit history
• The pursuit of new credit
• A mix of credit

When it comes to auto insurance and your credit score, drivers with better scores will usually have better rates. With that in mind, here’s a look at what Geico and Progressive charge customers with good, fair, and poor credit.

Geico vs Progressive Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Credit Score

We can see that Progressive customers are paying higher rates across the board, whether they have good, fair, or poor credit. In fact, the difference between the two companies is the largest among drivers with good credit, at $1,194.03.

A higher credit score = LOWER INSURANCE RATES😲. With inflation high⬆️, finding ways to cut costs💸has become more important than ever. 👉Price compare rates here: https://t.co/TSq0vDEjME
Learn other ways to lower your auto insurance rates🚗: https://t.co/pHF47vG6hP pic.twitter.com/ddqUMtUpCo

— AutoInsurance.org (@AutoInsurance) February 18, 2023

However, where the rates between Geico and Progressive are closest are for those with poor credit. Even though Progressive has a higher average rate, the difference between the two is under $500.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance by Annual Mileage

For many drivers, more miles tend to translate into higher rates. The rationale? The more you drive, the more likely you are to get into an accident.

When we compared what Geico and Progressive customers are paying according to their average annual mileage, we discovered that once more, Geico has the advantage:

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Annual Mileage

However, what should be noted among both insurers is that the difference between what customers are paying for 10-mile or 25-mile commutes is minimal, particularly among Progressive customers. For Progressive drivers, the difference between the two is only $10.99.

If you put fewer than 10,000 miles on your car annually, you may qualify for a low-mileage car insurance discount. Geico doesn’t offer this sort of savings, but Progressive does offer one of the best low-mileage auto insurance discounts.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Options

We get it. In the face of the worst-case scenario, you want to be sure that you’re covered. Whether a car insurance company offers the coverages you’re looking for will make all the difference in the world.

For some, it’ll be a matter of simply carrying basic coverages. For others, the distinguishing factor will be in the extras. This is why we’re breaking down Geico and Progressive’s coverage options below. When it comes to basic car insurance coverages, you can count on both Geico and Progressive to have what you need:

• Liability Insurance: This covers injuries or property damage resulting from an accident that you caused. Of the two, Geico usually offers the cheapest liability-only auto insurance plans.
• Collision Insurance: Collision insurance covers damage to your car as a result of a collision with another car, or a stationary object like a tree.
• Comprehensive Insurance: If your car is damaged outside an accident, comprehensive auto insurance may cover the repairs. Comprehensive insurance typically covers damage from non-collision events such as weather, vandalism, or theft.
• Medical Payments/Personal Injury Protection:  Regardless of who was at fault, medical payments and personal injury protection (PIP) insurance covers medical expenses for you and other passengers in your car.
• Uninsured Motorist/Underinsured Motorist: Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage helps cover costs if you’ve been involved in an accident with an at-fault driver who doesn’t have car insurance or has insufficient coverage.

If you’d like to add additional coverage beyond the basis, Geico and Progressive offer a good selection of add-ons. Both companies offer the following types of coverage:

• Accident Forgiveness
• Rental Car Reimbursement
• Rideshare
• Roadside Assistance

Keep in mind that not all types of insurance are available everywhere. For example, Geico rideshare insurance is only available in 40 states.

It may be the cheaper option, but Geico auto insurance reviews often mention the lack of coverage options this company offers. Here are the additional coverages that Progressive offers, but Geico does not:

• Gap Insurance: If a car that you’re financing or leasing is totaled or stolen, gap insurance covers the difference between what your car is worth and what you owe. For instance, let’s say your car is worth $5,000 but you have a balance of $10,000. If your car were to be totaled, your gap insurance would pay the $5,000 difference.
• Custom Parts and Equipment: According to the insurer, this form of insurance will repair or replace items that you add to your car (such as a stereo, navigation system, custom wheels, or a paint job).
• Deductible Savings Bank: This coverage allows drivers to subtract $50 from their collision and comprehensive deductibles for every claim-free policy period.

If you’re interested in any of these Progressive auto insurance add-ons, you can always check with a representative to see if they are available in your state.

While add-ons are a great way to protect your car, they will increase your monthly premium. Make sure to only purchase what you need to avoid expensive premiums.

Geico vs. Progressive Usage-Based Insurance

Drivers looking to take advantage of a usage-based insurance (UBI) program have options with both insurers. However, what drivers need to keep in mind is that these programs are vastly different.

If you’re wondering, “Is Geico or Progressive better for UBI savings?”, most drivers agree that Progressive is the best choice. With Progressive, drivers have access to what is commonly known as a pioneer in the UBI market—Snapshot.

Snapshot is an easy-to-use UBI program with options to track your driving through either the Progressive or with a plug-in device. Drivers with the safest habits on the road can save up to 30% on their insurance with Snapshot.

Geico’s DriveEasy is relatively new and among the newest players in the UBI space. As of now, Geico’s website promises savings of up to 25% to those who enroll but does not elaborate on any additional savings.

DriveEasy is powered by a mobile app, with a focus on developing safer driving habits. Right now, DriveEasy is only available in Connecticut and Pennsylvania, but the insurer promises to continue its expansion into other locations.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Discounts

There’s no question about it — car insurance discounts are a surefire way to get more bang for your buck. At the end of the day, your best bargains will rely entirely on which insurer can most closely meet you where you are. Check below to see some of the top discounts Geico and Progressive offer.

Auto Insurance Discounts for Geico vs. Progressive

Both companies offer solid discounts to help their drivers save, but Geico offers a few more than Progressive. However, the best company for you depends on your unique needs.

For example, Geico offers special discounts for military members and federal employees. Progressive, on the other hand, offers unique ways to save for teen drivers.

Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Customer Reviews

When it comes to Progressive and Geico car insurance reviews, both companies get predominantly positive reviews. However, Geico is often the more popular choice because it tends to be cheaper. For example, take the experience of this Reddit user, who found much cheaper rates at Geico.

Geico vs Progressive
byu/joons_knees inInsurance

Most of the comments from other Reddit users agreed that they found cheaper insurance quotes with Geico.

Although the answer to “Is Progressive cheaper than Geico?” is usually no, Progressive still deserves consideration. Many drivers agree that paying a little extra at Progressive is worth it to access the company’s superior digital tools. Progressive also offers more insurance variety than Geico, so it’s a popular choice for people looking for full coverage.

Of course, not all reviews are positive. For Progressive, customers often complain about unexpected rate increases, even when nothing about their policies had changed.

As for Geico, many customers report problems with the customer service experience. Additionally, if you want to bundle your policies for a discount, Geico home insurance reviews mention that the company doesn’t write its own policies. If you don’t want to buy home insurance from one of Geico’s partners, then you should bundle policies elsewhere.

Geico vs. Progressive: Auto Insurance Business Reviews

As some of the largest insurance providers in the country, it probably comes as no surprise that both Progressive and Geico have solid reviews from third-party rating companies. Check below to compare Geico Insurance vs. Progressive Insurance ratings from popular third-party rating companies.

Insurance Business Ratings & Consumer Reviews: Geico vs. Progressive

As you can see, both companies have similar ratings. However, Progressive has a higher score from the NAIC, which means it receives more customer complaints than Geico. On the other hand, Geico has a better score from A.M. Best, meaning it’s a more financially secure company than Progressive.

So, is Geico better than Progressive? Not necessarily. More customers have trusted Progressive with their insurance needs over Geico, as you can see in a comparison of each company’s market share below.

With both Progressive and Geico earning similar ratings, you’ll be in good hands no matter which company you pick. The best way to decide which is best for you is to compare discounts, coverage options, and how you’ll manage your policy.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Compare Geico vs. Progressive Auto Insurance Rates Today

Geico and Progressive are similar companies in many ways, with the primary difference being rates. Geico is the overall cheaper option, unless you have a DUI on your driving record. However, Progressive offers more coverage options than Geico and a more modern insurance experience.

Now that you’ve compared Geico vs. Progressive auto insurance, it’s time to start comparing rates. Enter your ZIP code into our free comparison tool today to see which company has the best prices for you.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption