American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance in 2025 (Head-to-Head Review)
When comparing American Family vs. Erie auto insurance, Erie is the more affordable option, with a minimum rate starting at $32 per month. Erie also offers Rate Lock to freeze low premiums. American Family Insurance starts at $62 per month, and it offers 30% off with KnowYourDrive usage-based savings.
Free Car Insurance Comparison
Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Eric Stauffer
Licensed Insurance Agent
Eric Stauffer is an insurance agent and banker-turned-consumer advocate. His priority is educating individuals and families about the different types of insurance coverage. He is passionate about helping consumers find the best coverage for their budgets and personal needs. Eric is the CEO of C Street Media, a full-service marketing firm and the co-founder of ProperCents.com, a financial educat...
Licensed Insurance Agent
UPDATED: Jun 15, 2025
It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.
Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident auto insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one auto insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.
UPDATED: Jun 15, 2025
It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.
Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident auto insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one auto insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.
On This Page
2,235 reviewsCompany Facts
Min. Coverage
A.M. Best
Complaint Level
Pros & Cons
2,235 reviews
1,883 reviewsCompany Facts
Min. Coverage
A.M. Best Rating
Complaint Level
Pros & Cons
1,883 reviewsCompare American Family vs. Erie auto insurance in our company review. Both providers have excellent customer feedback and low rates, but only cover a handful of states.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Rating
| Rating Criteria |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 4.0 | 4.3 |
| Business Reviews | 4.0 | 4.5 |
| Claim Processing | 4.8 | 4.3 |
| Company Reputation | 4.5 | 4.5 |
| Coverage Availability | 2.0 | 2.2 |
| Coverage Value | 4.0 | 4.6 |
| Customer Satisfaction | 3.9 | 3.5 |
| Digital Experience | 4.5 | 4.0 |
| Discounts Available | 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Insurance Cost | 3.8 | 4.7 |
| Plan Personalization | 4.5 | 4.5 |
| Policy Options | 3.4 | 5.0 |
| Savings Potential | 4.2 | 4.7 |
| American Family Review | Erie Review |
American Family KnowYourDrive offers cheap usage-based auto insurance for safe drivers by tracking real-time behaviors. Erie’s Rate Lock protects customers from future price hikes by freezing premiums unless significant policy changes occur.
- American Family and Erie auto insurance require full-term payments
- Erie excludes rideshare drivers from Rate Lock program eligibility
- AmFam’s KnowYourDrive adjusts savings after 93 days of safe driving
If AmFam and Erie aren’t available near you, you can quickly compare affordable auto insurance options in your area by entering your ZIP code into our quote tool to view the best local rates.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Rates
The cost of full coverage auto insurance varies significantly based on your age and gender. Erie has cheaper rates than American Family in all cases.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Age & Gender
| Age & Gender | | |
|---|---|---|
| 16-Year-Old Female | $230 | $121 |
| 16-Year-Old Male | $296 | $136 |
| 30-Year-Old Female | $62 | $34 |
| 30-Year-Old Male | $73 | $35 |
| 45-Year-Old Female | $62 | $32 |
| 45-Year-Old Male | $62 | $32 |
| 60-Year-Old Female | $57 | $30 |
| 60-Year-Old Male | $58 | $31 |
Teen drivers, mainly males, have the highest insurance costs. As drivers age, these prices decrease significantly. Erie maintains cheap auto insurance for 16-year-olds, but has very low rates for everyone, regardless of their age group.
Erie turns out to be the cheapest choice, even when you compare Erie Insurance vs. American Family against the nation’s biggest insurance companies. Erie’s monthly rates start at only $32 for minimum coverage and $83 for full.
Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Coverage Level & Provider
| Insurance Company | Minimum Coverage | Full Coverage |
|---|---|---|
 | $87 | $228 |
| $62 | $166 |
| $32 | $83 |
 | $76 | $198 |
 | $43 | $114 |
 | $96 | $248 |
 | $63 | $164 |
 | $56 | $150 |
 | $47 | $123 |
 | $53 | $141 |
American Family is found in the middle range and could be the cheapest provider in your area when you compare auto insurance rates by state. Compare more quotes in our American Family review.
American Family vs. Erie Insurance by Driving Record
A driving record greatly affects the cost of full coverage. The table indicates that Erie remains almost half as cheap compared to American Family, regardless of any violations.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Driving Record
| Driving Record | | |
|---|---|---|
| Clean Record | $62 | $32 |
| One Ticket | $73 | $38 |
| One Accident | $94 | $45 |
| One DUI | $104 | $60 |
Erie’s rates remain more lenient for high-risk drivers, especially if you need cheap auto insurance after a DUI. Monthly rates still double after a DUI, but Erie still costs less than $100 a month for minimum coverage.
Whether it’s a DUI, an at-fault accident, or a speeding ticket, Erie remains the most affordable option for drivers with a less-than-perfect record. However, high-risk drivers usually aren’t eligible for Erie Rate Lock or usage-based options.
Free Auto Insurance Comparison
Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Auto Insurance Coverage Options From American Family and Erie
Both American Family and Erie Insurance offer important coverage options, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Coverage Options
| Coverage Type | What it Covers | | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability | Damages to others in an accident | ✅ | ✅ |
| Collision | Damage to your car in an accident | ✅ | ✅ |
| Comprehensive | Non-collision damage to your car | ✅ | ✅ |
| Personal Injury Protection (PIP) | Medical expenses and lost wages | ✅ | ✅ |
| Uninsured Motorist | Protection if hit by an uninsured driver | ✅ | ✅ |
| Underinsured Motorist | Protection if hit by an underinsured driver | ✅ | ✅ |
| Roadside Assistance | Towing and emergency help | ✅ | ✅ |
| Rental Car | Covers rental car expenses during repair | ✅ | ✅ |
| Gap Insurance | Covers car loan balance if totaled | ✅ | ✅ |
| Medical Payments (MedPay) | Medical expenses for you and passengers | ✅ | ✅ |
They also offer additional services, including gap insurance, roadside assistance, and rental reimbursement. Medical protection is also very complete, offering both personal injury protection and medical payments. Neither insurance company leaves big gaps in coverage.
Erie offers more add-on policies than American Family. Drivers with Erie auto insurance can add pet injury and personal item coverage.
You can also add Erie Rate Lock to your policy to lock in cheap rates regardless of claims or driving behavior. However, customers like this one note that rates can often triple if you add a new car or driver to your policy.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Discounts
Both companies offer a 25% discount for bundling services. However, Erie stands out with a 30% low-mileage discount and somewhat better savings for going paperless. Find more savings in our Erie Insurance review.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Discount Savings Compared
| Discount Type | | |
|---|---|---|
| Bundling | 25% | 25% |
| Anti-Theft | 25% | 15% |
| Low Mileage | 20% | 30% |
| Good Student | 20% | 15% |
| Pay-in-Full | 20% | 15% |
| Multi-Car | 20% | 10% |
| Safe Driver | 18% | 15% |
| Safety Features | 18% | 10% |
| Defensive Driving | 5% | 5% |
| Paperless | 4% | 5% |
Both companies offer competitive 30% discounts on usage-based insurance if drivers sign up for American Family KnowYourDrive or YourTurn from Erie. The best savings depend on your driving habits and the frequency of your driving.
American Family offers better discounts on anti-theft measures, good student drivers, multiple cars, and tech-based vehicle safety features.
American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance Reviews & Ratings
Erie receives better scores in almost all categories, according to J.D. Power and Consumer Reports. It keeps better financial strength, gets fewer complaints, and overall receives more positive feedback.
Insurance Business Ratings & Consumer Reviews: American Family vs. Erie
| Agency | | |
|---|---|---|
 | Score: 692 / 1,000 Below Avg. Satisfaction | Score: 733 / 1,000 Avg. Satisfaction |
 | Score: A+ Excellent Business Practices | Score: A+ Excellent Business Practices |
 | Score: 78/100 Positive Customer Feedback | Score: 82/100 Positive Customer Feedback |
 | Score: 0.26 Fewer Complaints Than Avg. | Score: 0.60 Fewer Complaints Than Avg. |
 | Score: A Excellent Financial Strength | Score: A+ Superior Financial Strength |
American Family is slightly behind in terms of satisfaction and consumer experience, despite having a good A.M. Best rating. American Family also has a slightly bigger share of the market at 2.0% compared to Erie’s 1.4%.
Both companies are still small players in a market controlled by big national carriers. However, they each build loyal customers through local agents.
Read more: Who are the reputable auto insurance companies?
Free Auto Insurance Comparison
Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
What to Remember About American Family vs. Erie Auto Insurance
American Family vs. Erie auto insurance have distinct strengths, making them suitable for different types of drivers. American Family is notable for offering bigger discounts, including usage-based discounts, which you can compare in our AmFam KnowYourDrive review.
View this post on Instagram
Erie is attractive to those seeking long-term savings, offering options like Rate Lock and generally lower prices for many groups and driving histories.
Erie limits availability to 12 states while American Family is in 19. As such, moving out of Erie or AmFam’s service area may require switching insurers.Brandon Frady Licensed Insurance Producer
Choosing between them depends on how you drive, what coverage you need, and which discounts best fit your needs. Discover your best match by entering your ZIP code into our free quote comparison tool.
Your Opinion Matters!
Rate your insurance provider and provide share feedback with shoppers just like you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is American Family Insurance a good company for your coverage needs?
Yes, American Family Insurance is well-rated for customer satisfaction, offering competitive monthly premiums, solid financial strength, and customizable coverage plans. Compare American Family vs. Geico auto insurance to see what else sets it apart.
Is Erie a good auto insurance company?
Yes, Erie is considered a reputable auto insurance company, boasting an A+ A.M. Best rating, a strong customer service reputation, and low monthly rates in many states.
Is Erie Amerika the same as Erie Insurance?
No, Erie Amerika isn’t a recognized branch of Erie Insurance. You may be referring to Erie Insurance Group, which serves several U.S. states with a range of auto, home, and life insurance options.
What does the American Family Home Insurance Company offer you as a homeowner?
American Family home insurance provides property protection, liability coverage, and optional endorsements like identity theft and equipment breakdown at competitive monthly rates. See how it compares to the best companies for home and auto insurance bundles.
Is American Family Insurance better than State Farm for your needs?
That depends on what you value most. American Family may offer lower monthly rates and more competitive bundling discounts, while State Farm is recognized for its broader agent network and higher customer satisfaction scores in certain regions. Compare American Family vs. State Farm auto insurance for more reviews.
What is Erie Insurance’s A.M. Best rating?
You’ll find an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best for Erie Insurance, indicating strong financial stability and a reliable claims-paying ability.
Can you get life insurance from Erie Family Life Insurance Co.?
Yes, Erie offers term, whole, and universal life insurance products tailored to fit your budget and long-term financial goals, often with flexible monthly payment options.
Why is there an Erie insurance homeowners rate increase?
You may see a homeowners rate increase with Erie due to rising repair costs, increased claim frequency, or inflation; however, bundling policies could help lower your monthly premiums.
Is Erie vs. Amica home insurance a fair comparison for your policy search?
Yes, comparing Erie vs. Amica home insurance helps to evaluate value and service. Typically, Erie offers lower monthly rates, but Amica is recognized for its excellent customer service. See more in our Amica auto insurance review.
Is American Family good at paying claims?
Yes, American Family is known for timely claims processing, with most customers reporting satisfactory payouts and responsive support during the claims process.
Why is American Family so expensive?
American Family may seem expensive due to factors like your location, driving record, or coverage selections, but bundling can help reduce your monthly premiums. Enter your ZIP code to find affordable car insurance near you.
Why is Erie insurance so expensive in your area?
Erie Insurance may charge higher monthly rates if you have a history of claims, reside in a high-risk area, or add optional coverages such as new car replacement or accident forgiveness.
Is American Family Insurance losing customers?
American Family has faced some retention challenges due to rising premiums and regional competition, but it continues to serve millions of policyholders in 19 states. Learn how auto insurance competition helps customers get lower rates.
Who owns American Family Insurance?
American Family Insurance is a mutual company, which means it’s owned by its policyholders, not shareholders, allowing it to reinvest profits back into customer benefits.
Eric Stauffer
Licensed Insurance Agent
Eric Stauffer is an insurance agent and banker-turned-consumer advocate. His priority is educating individuals and families about the different types of insurance coverage. He is passionate about helping consumers find the best coverage for their budgets and personal needs. Eric is the CEO of C Street Media, a full-service marketing firm and the co-founder of ProperCents.com, a financial educat...
Licensed Insurance Agent
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.
