Best Gap Insurance in 2025 (Your Guide to the Top 10 Companies)

State Farm, Progressive, and Nationwide offer the best gap insurance on the market with rates as low as $8 per month. Gap customers can sign up for usage-based insurance to save even more money.

When comparing top gap insurance companies and reading gap insurance company reviews, you’ll find that guaranteed auto protection insurance is great for customers looking for extra protection for their new vehicles. Other top companies that offer excellent gap coverage are listed below.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Gap Insurance

Read on to learn more about the best gap insurance companies and pick one that’s right for you. You can also compare rates at top companies by entering your ZIP in our free quote comparison tool.

#1 – State Farm: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Customer Service: Customers shopping for gap coverage can talk directly to local agents.
• Affordable Rates: State Farm has affordable average rates for gap insurance. Learn more about rates in our State Farm auto insurance review.
• Bundling Discount: Auto insurance customers will save on gap insurance if they also get their home or renters insurance from State Farm.

Cons

• Financial Stability: The company’s rating from A.M. Best could be much better than other companies who offer gap insurance on our list.
• Online Management Limitations: Customers will have to contact local agents for help with most tasks related to gap insurance.

#2 – Progressive: Best for Online Tools

Pros

• Online Tools: Progressive has an online app, a budget calculator, and more for its gap insurance customers.
• Snapshot Discount: Gap customers can join Snapshot to earn lower rates for safe driving habits.
• Loyalty Rewards: Progressive offers discounts on gap insurance and other perks for loyal customers. Our review of Progressive delves more into its perks.

Cons

• Snapshot Gap Rate Increases: Snapshot is best for good drivers, as poor driving could raise rates in some states.
• Gap Claim Customer Satisfaction: The quality of service for customers filing gap claims doesn’t always receive the best gap insurance reviews.

#3 – Nationwide: Best for Bundling Discounts

Pros

• Bundling Discounts: Auto insurance customers can save on gap insurance by also purchasing their home or renters insurance from Nationwide.
• SmartMiles Coverage: Low-mileage drivers can opt for pay-per-mile insurance for cheaper rates on gap coverage.
• Accident Forgiveness: Good drivers could avoid gap rate increases if they qualify for accident forgiveness.

Cons

• Customer Satisfaction: There are varying reviews about the quality of service for customers filing gap claims at Nationwide, which you can learn about in our Nationwide auto insurance review.
• Affordability for Bad Drivers: A poor driving record will make Nationwide’s gap insurance quotes less affordable compared to competitors.

#4 – Allstate: Best for Infrequent Drivers

Pros

• Infrequent Drivers: As one of the best gap insurance providers, Allstate offers cheaper gap insurance rates for low mileage drivers. Allstate also offers pay-per-mile insurance in some states.
• Safe Driving Discounts: Gap customers can join Drivewise to earn a good driving discount.
• Adjustable Deductibles: Gap insurance customers can change their deductibles. Learn more in our Allstate auto insurance review.

Cons

• Young Driver Gap Rates: Allstate isn’t affordable compared to other companies’ prices for young drivers.
• Customer Complaints About Gap Claims: The quality of claims service has a higher-than-average number of complaints.

#5 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Customizable Policies

Pros

• Customizable Policies: Among insurance companies that offer gap, Liberty Mutual has great customizable policies, as customers can adjust deductibles on their gap insurance.
• Multi-Vehicle Gap Discount: Customers who are insuring more than one vehicle will get a lower rate on gap insurance. For more gap insurance comparison options, read our Liberty Mutual auto insurance review.
• Accident Forgiveness: Liberty Mutual forgives first accidents for safe drivers, so gap insurance rates rates won’t increase.

Cons

• Gap Coverage Affordability for High-Risk Drivers: Liberty Mutual isn’t a top company for affordability for high-risk customers.
• Customer Satisfaction With Gap Claims: There are some complaints about the quality of service.

#6 – Farmers: Best for Signal App

Pros

• Signal App: Safe drivers can earn a discount on gap insurance from Signal after successfully completing the program.
• Adjustable Deductibles: For a detailed gap car insurance comparison, check out our Farmers auto insurance review to see how gap customers can adjust deductibles.
• Discount Options: Gap customers can bundle coverages, go paperless, and more to save on coverage.

Cons

• Customer Service: There are varying reviews about the quality of service from Farmers, such as filing gap claims.
• Accident Forgiveness Costs Extra: While most companies offer accident forgiveness for free, Farmers require customers to pay a small additional fee to avoid increased rates on gap insurance.

#7 – Travelers: Best for Unique Coverage

Pros

• Unique Coverage: As a top gap insurance provider, Travelers has great coverage options besides just gap coverage. Read more in our Travelers auto insurance review.
• IntelliDrive Program: Safe driving habits will earn customers a discount on gap insurance.
• Financial Stability: Travelers is one of the most financially stable gap companies on the market.

Cons

• IntelliDrive Rate Increases: Only safe drivers should join IntelliDrive, as bad driving could increase gap rates.
• Customer Reviews: There are some negative reviews about the quality of service, such as gap claims.

#8 – American Family: Best for Loyalty Rewards

Pros

• Loyalty Rewards: As one of the best gap auto insurance providers, loyal customers will earn gap discounts and other perks.
• Multi-Vehicle Gap Discount: American Family discounts gap insurance for multi-vehicle policies. Visit our American Family auto insurance review for a full discount list.
• Good Driver Discount: Good drivers can reduce rates by joining the KnowYourDrive UBI program.

Cons

• Availability: American Family doesn’t sell gap auto insurance in all 50 U.S. states.
• Online Management: American Family may offer less comprehensive online functions to manage gap insurance due to local agent availability.

#9 – The Hartford: Best for Tailored Policies

Pros

• Tailored Policies: The Hartford works with customers to tailor gap policies to meet their needs.
• AARP Discount: The Hartford offers discounted gap insurance coverage to AARP members.
• Accident Forgiveness: The Hartford won’t raise gap rates on some accidents. Learn more in our review of The Hartford.

Cons

• Young Driver Gap Rates: The Hartford specializes in insurance for senior drivers, so its rates aren’t as great for young drivers.
• Customer Reviews: The quality of service for gap claims has mixed reviews from customers.

#10 – Auto-Owners: Best for Reliable Service

Pros

• Reliability Focused: Auto-Owners focuses on reliability for its gap customers, which you can learn about in our review of Auto-Owners.
• Financial Stability: Auto-Owners is more financially stable than most of its gap insurance competitors.
• Online Payments: Customers can pay for gap insurance online.

Cons

• Availability: Auto-Owners is not available in all states.
• Online Functions: Auto-Owners’ app and website don’t allow customers to perform as many online functions as other companies.

Average Auto Insurance Rates With Gap Coverage

What is gap insurance? Gap insurance is an affordable add-on coverage, as it costs less than $10 per month at most top companies when added to a minimum coverage policy. Compare gap insurance from top providers below:

Gap Insurance Monthly Rates by Coverage Level & Provider

According to gap car insurance reviews, gap coverage is recommended for most new cars that still have a lease or loan on them, as it ensures that customers with a totaled car don’t have to continue to pay off a lease or loan to a car they no longer own (Read More: How do insurance companies value totaled cars?).

Our Catastrophe Response Team is on the ground and ready to help customers recover from the devastating wildfires. https://t.co/Ad5q6XAYIy

— State Farm (@StateFarm) January 28, 2025

Because gap coverage is so affordable, new vehicle owners should consider carrying it for the first year or two of ownership. You should also get the best gap coverage as possible as it is an affordable add on.

Pros and Cons of Gap Insurance

According to gap insurance reviews and gap insurance comparison sites, understanding the advantages and disadvantages of gap coverage is crucial before purchasing.

Based on leading auto gap insurance providers, gap insurance protects you from financial loss if your new vehicle is totaled. Insurance companies that offer gap coverage explain that this protection is especially valuable when you owe more on your loan than your car is worth.

While this protection is valuable, gap insurance isn’t necessary for everyone. According to various gap insurance providers, drivers who made a large down payment or have paid off most of their loan may not need this coverage.

How to Save Money on Gap Insurance

For those getting price comparisons for gap insurance, there are a few things drivers can do if adding on extras like gap makes car insurance too expensive. The first is to check out auto insurance discounts at your company.

Even little discounts like safety feature discounts will lower gap insurance costs and make it more affordable for customers.

If applying for discounts doesn’t make gap coverage more affordable, then drivers can also shop around at different companies to find cheap gap insurance rates.

Drivers will also find that the longer they keep a clean driving record, the lower their rates will fall over time. Insurance providers also offer deals for good drivers, like diminishing deductibles and accident forgiveness.

Finding the Best Gap Insurance Company for You

Gap coverage is the best auto insurance for leased vehicles that are brand new. You will find the best gap insurance at companies like State Farm, Progressive, and Nationwide.

Ready to shop for the best gap insurance today? Compare rates now with our free quote comparison tool to get the best deal on insurance companies with gap coverage.