Ashley Dannelly

Social Media Manager & Professor

Ashley Dannelly has a Master of Arts in English and serves as the Social Media Manager for Quote.com's portfolio of websites. Ashley also teaches English at Columbia International University and other higher education institutions. Ashley’s background in English and media has allowed her the unique opportunity to edit and create content for many publications, including Livestrong and DiveIn....

Written by
Ashley Dannelly
Aleksandra J. Churlinov

Managing Editor

Aleksandra J. Churlinov holds a Bachelor of Arts in English Language and Literature and a Master of Science in Marketing Management. Over the past six years, Aleks has focused on the insurance sector, working on a range of content, including business, auto, and life insurance. In April 2025, she stepped into the role of Managing Editor, where she now leads a team of talented insurance writers. ...

Scott W. Johnson

Licensed Insurance Agent

Scott W Johnson is an independent insurance agent in California. Principal Broker and founder of Marindependent Insurance Services, Scott brings over 25 years of experience to his clients. His Five President’s Council awards prove he uses all he learned at Avocet, Sprint Nextel, and Farmers Insurance to the benefit of his clients. Scott quickly grasped the unique insurance requirements of his...

Reviewed by
Scott W. Johnson

Updated November 2026

Erie, Auto-Owners, and Geico have some of the cheapest auto insurance for older vehicles, with rates starting at $564 per year.

Things to remember

  • Drop collision or comprehensive if costs outweigh your car’s value
  • Some discounts cut rates by 30% for drivers who drive less
  • Switch to liability-only if full coverage costs outweigh your car’s value

Erie’s Rate Lock can keep premiums for an older car from changing as long as you don’t make a qualifying change to your policy.

Auto-Owners offers collision benefits that may reduce or eliminate your deductible for certain covered claims.

9 Best Companies: Cheapest Auto Insurance for Older Vehicles

CompanyRankMonthly
Rates
Claims
Satisfaction
Best for
Erie#1$47743 / 1,000Cheapest Overall
Auto-Owners#2$51711 / 1,000Common Losses
Geico#3$52697 / 1,000Online Convenience
Travelers#4$56691 / 1,000Coverage Options
State Farm#5$58716 / 1,000Agency Network
Progressive#6$64673 / 1,000Minor Accidents
Nationwide#7$66729 / 1,000Claims Support
Farmers#8$82690 / 1,000Various Discounts
Allstate#9$86693 / 1,000Deductible Rewards

Compare RatesStart Now →

Geico has mechanical breakdown insurance for eligible vehicles, which can help pay for certain covered repairs beyond routine maintenance.

Enter your ZIP code to compare personalized rates, coverage options, and find the best insurance for older cars in your area.

Comparing Auto Insurance Rates for Older Vehicles

Older vehicle insurance rates depend on the car’s value, annual mileage, repair costs, deductible, and how much coverage the driver carries. These factors can help drivers decide which coverage still makes sense for an older car.

Full coverage costs noticeably more because it adds collision and comprehensive protection, which may become harder to justify as a car loses value.

Auto Insurance Monthly Rates for Older Cars by Coverage Level

Insurance CompanyMinimum CoverageFull Coverage
Allstate$86$234
Auto-Owners$51$167
Erie$47$151
Farmers$82$229
Geico$52$163
Nationwide$66$187
Progressive$64$190
State Farm$58$174
Travelers$56$158

Compare RatesStart Now →

The $500 deductible matters because drivers must pay that amount before collision or comprehensive coverage starts contributing to the cost of repairs.

Even if an older car’s resale value has fallen, repairs can still be expensive when replacement parts are costly or difficult to find. This can also be an important consideration when shopping for auto insurance for classic vehicles.

An older car isn’t always cheaper to insure. Some models can cost more if they’re stolen more often.

Jeff Root Licensed Insurance Agent

When people finance cars, they are generally required to carry both collision and comprehensive coverage until the loan is paid off, which limits their ability to lower premiums.

Once you fully own the car, compare quotes and weigh its value against coverage costs to find the cheapest auto insurance for older vehicles without paying for protection you no longer need.

State-by-State Car Insurance Rates for Older Cars

Where you live can make a big difference in what you pay each month, which is why car insurance rates by state matter.

Before keeping full coverage, check your car’s current value and decide whether a future claim payout would justify the extra premium.

Drivers with paid-off cars can consider minimum car insurance coverage required in most states, but they would pay their own repair costs after causing a crash.

Shopping around among local insurers can help you find the cheapest insurance for cars older than 20 years, since companies can price the same vehicle very differently.

How Credit Affects Older Vehicle Insurance Rates

Credit can have a bigger effect on the cost of insuring an older vehicle than many drivers expect, especially if they have lower credit scores.

One older car insurance trick is to compare credit-based auto insurance rates at renewal since insurers can weigh the same credit profile differently.

Check your credit report for incorrect balances, late payments, or accounts that aren’t yours, and dispute any errors before your next renewal.

Credit can still affect your car insurance rate even if your older vehicle is worth less. When renewing, check your credit report and get quotes from several insurers to find the best rate.

Get More Details: How Credit Scores Affect Car Insurance Rates

Older Vehicle Insurance After Accidents and DUIs

A traffic violation can make insurance for an older car expensive compared to the car’s value.

Before switching insurers after an accident, check whether your existing policy’s accident forgiveness benefit applies to the accident, then compare auto insurance quotes for older cars.

In some states, a DUI might require SR-22 insurance, and high-risk car insurance offers options for drivers with limited standard coverage choices.

An SR-22 is a form that proves you carry the required liability coverage, not a separate type of insurance policy. A DUI can also lead to higher premiums and license restrictions.

What Happens After a DUI or DWI Arrest Infographic

Since insurers look at a person’s driving record over several years, an accident or traffic violation can still affect premiums when renewing auto insurance for antique vehicles.

Once a violation falls outside an insurer’s review period, it may have less effect on your rate, so compare quotes again.

How Driver Age Affects Older Car Insurance

Assigning a teen driver to an older car doesn’t always guarantee cheap auto insurance for older cars, since auto insurance rates by age can still have a big impact on pricing.

Families with several cars should check which vehicle each driver is assigned to, since adding a 16-year-old can affect the total premium.

Drivers in their mid-20s may want to get new quotes, since rates often decrease as they move out of the highest-priced age groups.

Drivers nearing 65 may want to compare rates again, since premiums can begin to rise with age even with the same car and a clean driving record. Good student and driver’s ed discounts may help eligible younger drivers lower their premiums.

Good Student Discount Definition Card

Many insurers require students to maintain at least a B average or 3.0 GPA to qualify for a good student discount.

Keeping a young driver on a family policy is often less expensive than buying a separate policy for them.

Continue Reading: Male vs. Female Car Insurance Rates

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide Progressive Allstate

Coverage Options for Car Insurance for Older Vehicles

For an older vehicle, focus on coverage for losses you’d have difficulty paying for out of pocket.

Collision coverage pays for covered crash damage minus your deductible, so compare the cost of the coverage with your older car’s value. Other coverages may protect against losses that collision coverage doesn’t cover.

  • Comprehensive Coverage: Pays for covered non-collision losses involving older vehicles, including theft, fire, hail, flooding, vandalism, falling objects, and animal strikes.
  • Medical Payments Coverage: Helps cover accident-related medical bills for you and your passengers, regardless of who caused the crash.
  • Rental Reimbursement: Pays toward temporary transportation when a covered claim leaves your older vehicle in the repair shop.
  • Roadside Assistance: Helps with towing, battery jump-starts, lockouts, flat-tire changes, and fuel delivery when an older vehicle breaks down.
  • Uninsured Motorist Coverage: Helps cover eligible injuries or vehicle damage when an uninsured or underinsured driver causes the accident, depending on state rules.

Coverage limits and deductibles affect how much your policy may pay after a covered loss and how much you’ll pay out of pocket. A higher deductible can lower your premium, but you’ll pay more toward a covered claim before insurance pays.

Older car owners may want higher liability limits if state minimum coverage wouldn’t cover the full cost of an accident.

Ask what replacement parts your insurer uses for older cars, since original parts may be harder to find.

Michelle Robbins Licensed Insurance Agent

When comparing auto insurance for old vehicles, check whether aftermarket parts or custom upgrades need extra coverage, since a standard policy may not fully cover their value.

Compare optional car insurance coverage to find cheap auto insurance for older vehicles without paying for protection you may not need.

Ways to Save on Auto Insurance for Older Cars

Discounts for older vehicles can lower your insurance costs, but the biggest discount may not fit how you drive.

If you drive your older car only occasionally, consider a low-mileage discount or program. Your insurer may verify your mileage using odometer readings or telematics.

Top Auto Insurance Discounts for Older Vehicles

CompanyAnti-TheftGood DriverLow-MileageMulti-Vehicle
Allstate10%25%30%10%
Auto-Owners12%25%30%10%
Erie15%23%30%10%
Farmers10%30%10%12%
Geico25%22%27%25%
Nationwide5%40%20%15%
Progressive25%30%30%12%
State Farm15%25%12%20%
Travelers15%10%20%8%

Compare RatesStart Now →

Check which anti-theft devices, such as approved alarms, immobilizers, or tracking devices, qualify for a discount before buying new equipment.

If you have an older car and another vehicle, price both options before assuming a multi-car discount will save you money.

In addition to these discounts, a few coverage and policy changes can further reduce the cost of cheap car insurance for older vehicles.

An auto insurance discount can reduce premiums, but changing payment frequency, liability limits, and how the vehicle is used may also save you money.

  • Avoid Small Claims: For minor damage, compare the repair cost with your deductible before deciding whether to file a claim.
  • Compare Insurers at Renewal: Shop around before renewing because insurers can charge different rates for the same older vehicle.
  • Lower Liability Limits Carefully: Lowering your liability limits may reduce your premium, but it also leaves you with less financial protection if you cause an accident.
  • Review Collision Coverage: Compare your yearly collision premium and deductible with your older car’s current value to decide whether the coverage is still worth paying for.
  • Update Vehicle Usage: Update your insurer if an older car becomes a weekend or secondary vehicle, since how you use it can affect your premium.

These steps work alongside the discounts above rather than replacing them. Shopping around can help you get an affordable auto insurance quote when insurers price the same older vehicle differently.

Reviewing your policy at renewal can uncover more savings when your older car’s use, mileage, or insurance needs change.

Usage-Based Car Insurance for Older Vehicles

Usage-based insurance (UBI), also called telematics insurance, uses an app or device to track driving and calculate potential savings.

Drivers who keep an older car for occasional trips may benefit if the program rewards lower annual mileage.

The Nationwide SmartRide App offers savings up to 40%, the highest UBI savings among the insurers compared here.

Most programs compared use a mobile app, which can make UBI easier to use with older vehicles that may not support a plug-in telematics device.

How Usage-Based Car Insurance Works Infographic

Telematics programs may track acceleration, hard braking, mileage, speed, and time of day to see how safely and often you drive.

Before signing up, see if risky driving could raise your rate and make sure the program works with your older car.

Top Auto Insurance Providers for Older Vehicles

Erie, Auto-Owners, and Geico are among the best options for older vehicles when keeping monthly costs manageable is a priority.

Erie starts at $47 per month, while Auto-Owners comes in at $51 and gives drivers more flexibility when choosing coverage for an aging car.

Geico starts at $52 monthly and makes it easy to manage your policy online. When comparing the best auto insurance companies, check rates, discounts, and whether the coverage still makes sense for your older car’s value.

Bigger insurers can be convenient, but size alone doesn’t tell you whether you’re getting a good deal on an older vehicle. Rates can vary a lot from one company to another, so checking quotes is worth the extra few minutes.

#1 – Erie: Cheapest Overall

Pros

  • Lowest Monthly Rate: Erie offers minimum coverage starting at $47 a month, making it the cheapest of the nine insurers compared.
  • Deductible Reduction: Your collision deductible drops by $100 each claims-free year, up to $500, helping you pay less after an accident.
  • Three-Year Accident Forgiveness: After three eligible years, Erie may forgive your first at-fault accident without an accident-related rate increase.

Cons

  • Limited Deductible Availability: Erie’s diminishing deductible isn’t available everywhere, so some drivers can’t qualify for the $500 reduction.
  • Rate Lock Exceptions: As noted in our Erie insurance review, your rate can still change if you add or remove a car or driver or change where you keep your vehicle.

#2 – Auto-Owners: Best for Common Losses

Pros

  • Common Loss Deductible: When the same event damages your older car and home, Auto-Owners may reduce or waive the auto deductible based on the deductible.
  • Claims Satisfaction: Auto-Owners scored 711 out of 1K for claims satisfaction, a useful consideration when filing a claim for an older car.
  • Collision Deductible Waiver: You may not have to pay your collision deductible if you’re in a qualifying accident with another Auto-Owners-insured car.

Cons

  • 36-Month Eligibility Rule: You’ll need to go 36 months without paid at-fault claims or major violations to qualify for accident forgiveness.
  • No Direct Online Purchase: Auto-Owners requires an independent agent to buy coverage rather than purchasing online. Deep Dive: Auto-Owners Insurance Review

#3 – Geico: Best for Online Tools

Pros

  • Easy Online Access: Get quotes, check discounts, and manage your older car’s policy through Geico’s website or mobile app.
  • Clean-Driver Discount: Staying accident-free for one year may qualify you for savings of up to 22%, as detailed in our Geico insurance review.
  • Multi-Vehicle Savings: Insuring your older car alongside another eligible vehicle can qualify you for a multi-vehicle discount of up to 25%.

Cons

  • Limited Local Agent Access: Most policy services are handled online or by phone, which may not suit drivers who prefer working with a local agent.
  • DriveEasy Rate Risk: Risky driving habits recorded through DriveEasy could lead to higher premiums.

#4 – Travelers: Best for Coverage Options

Pros

  • Multiple Coverage Choices: Travelers’ Responsible Driver Plans include accident forgiveness, minor violation forgiveness, deductible reductions, and total-loss waivers.
  • Telematics Savings: IntelliDrive 365 offers up to 35% in renewal savings based on driving habits, plus up to 10% during the first policy term.
  • New-Car Replacement: Travelers offers optional new-car replacement coverage for eligible newer vehicles, though it generally won’t apply to older cars.

Cons

  • Telematics Rate Risk: Riskier driving recorded by IntelliDrive 365 could increase your renewal premium. Read More: Travelers Insurance Review
  • Limited State Availability: IntelliDrive 365 is available in 31 states, leaving drivers elsewhere without access to the program.

#5 – State Farm: Best for Agent Network

Pros

  • Local Agent Access: State Farm agents can help you compare coverage, adjust deductibles, and update your policy as your older car loses value.
  • Driving Discount: Our Drive Safe & Save review shows drivers with older vehicles get 10% off for joining and can save up to 30% based on how they drive.
  • Low-Mileage Savings: Our State Farm insurance review explains how Drive Safe & Save may help lower your rate if you don’t drive your older car much.

Cons

  • Classic Cars Excluded: Drive Safe & Save doesn’t cover antique or classic cars, so you can’t use the program to earn discounts on them.
  • Three-State Exclusion: Drive Safe & Save isn’t available in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island.

#6 – Progressive: Best for Minor Accidents

Pros

  • Small Accident Forgiveness: Progressive won’t raise your rate for a first qualifying claim of $500 or less. Related: Progressive Insurance Review
  • Snapshot Savings: Snapshot offers savings up to 30% based on driving habits, including mileage and braking behavior.
  • Multi-Car Savings: Insuring your older vehicle alongside another eligible car can qualify you for Progressive’s 12% multi-car discount.

Cons

  • Extra Program Cost: Deductible Savings Bank costs extra and requires comprehensive and collision coverage with at least a $500 deductible.
  • Five-Year Wait: Larger accident forgiveness benefits generally require five years of eligibility without qualifying accidents or violations.

#7 – Nationwide: Best for Claims Support

Pros

  • Claims Satisfaction: Nationwide scored 729 out of 1K for claims satisfaction, making its claims service worth considering when an older car needs repairs.
  • Pay-Per-Mile Pricing: SmartMiles works with most cars made after 1996 and may help lower your rate if you don’t drive much.
  • Road-Trip Cap: SmartMiles only counts the first 250 miles you drive each day, so longer trips won’t add as much to your bill.

Cons

  • Pre-1997 Restriction: As covered in our Nationwide insurance review, SmartMiles generally doesn’t work with vehicles made before 1997.
  • Compatibility Limits: Some older hybrid, electric, and diesel vehicles may not work with SmartMiles, even if they meet the model-year requirement.

#8 – Farmers: Best for Discount Variety

Pros

  • Plenty of Discounts: Farmers offers Signal, safe-driver, Auto Pay/EFT, and bundling discounts, giving drivers several ways to save on older vehicles.
  • Safe-Driver Savings: You may qualify for a discount after three years without chargeable accidents or traffic tickets.
  • Mileage-Based Savings: Signal considers mileage and driving behavior, which may benefit owners who use their older cars infrequently.

Cons

  • Trip Requirement: You’ll need to take 10 Signal trips within 30 days to keep the initial discount. Learn more in our Farmers insurance review.
  • Rate Increase Risk: Risky habits picked up by Signal, such as hard braking or late-night driving, could raise your rate at renewal.

#9 – Allstate: Best for Deductible Rewards

Pros

  • Deductible Rewards: Allstate reduces eligible collision deductibles by $100 at enrollment and another $100 each accident-free year, up to $500.
  • Drivewise Savings: Drivewise offers potential discounts based on recorded driving habits, including braking, speed, and time of day.
  • Free Crash Detection: Drivewise includes crash detection that can help connect drivers with emergency assistance, roadside support, or claims services.

Cons

  • Collision Coverage Required: Allstate Deductible Rewards requires collision coverage, so it won’t help drivers who have dropped that protection on lower-value cars.
  • 50-Trip Requirement: Our Allstate insurance review notes that you’ll need at least 50 Drivewise trips to maximize savings, which may be harder with less-driven older vehicles.

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide Progressive Allstate

Getting the Best Auto Insurance for Older Vehicles

Finding cheap auto insurance for older vehicles starts with understanding what your insurer would actually pay if the car were totaled.

Erie, Auto-Owners, and Geico are leading choices, but drivers should also compare the cheapest auto insurance companies using identical limits, insurance deductibles, and personal information when requesting quotes.

To estimate what your older vehicle may be worth after a total loss, a totaled car value calculator can provide a useful starting point before comparing it with the insurer’s valuation.

Your car’s mileage, condition, past damage, and local prices can all affect how much your insurer pays if it’s totaled.

If you don’t drive your older car much, ask your insurer if they offer a low-mileage option. It could help bring your rate down.

Melanie Musson Published Insurance Expert

Check your older car’s value against what you pay for collision and comprehensive coverage each year. If the premiums and deductible are close to what you could receive after a total loss, keeping both coverages may not be worth it.

Make sure to let your insurance company know if you’ve fitted any special equipment or restored major parts, and compare classic car insurance companies to see whether those upgrades need specialized coverage or documentation.

Before you choose a policy, compare your car’s value and likely claim payout with the cost of coverage, then use our free comparison tool to find coverage that fits your older vehicle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do insurance companies consider an older vehicle?

There’s no exact age that makes a vehicle “older,” but around 10 years is a common benchmark. Insurers also look at its value, mileage, condition, repair costs, and safety features.

What car insurance coverage is best for an older car?

Liability plus any state-required coverage may be enough for a low-value, paid-off older car. Collision and comprehensive can still be worth keeping if replacing the car yourself would be difficult.

Enter your ZIP code to discover affordable auto insurance options for older vehicles.

Do I need full coverage for an older car?

Not always. For a paid-off car, compare its value with collision auto insurance and comprehensive costs. If both are worthwhile, compare the cheapest full coverage auto insurance options.

When should I drop collision and comprehensive coverage on an older car?

Consider dropping them when the coverage starts costing too much compared to what your car is worth. A common rule is to reconsider them if the car is worth less than 10 times the annual premium.

Can I get full coverage on a 20-year-old car?

Yes, a 20-year-old car can still get full coverage. Just make sure the cost is worth it based on the car’s current value.

Lower rates for older cars may be easier to find with our free quote comparison tool.

How can I get cheaper car insurance for an older car?

Start by shopping around to find affordable auto insurance rates online and compare quotes to see where you can save. You can also check for discounts, drop coverage you don’t need, or choose a higher deductible.

Are older cars more expensive to insure?

Not necessarily. An older vehicle may cost less to insure as it loses value, but factors that affect auto insurance rates, like repair costs, mileage, location, driving history, and coverage choices, can still push the price up.

Is $300 a month too much for insurance on an older car?

For many lower-value older cars, $300 a month is on the expensive side. Check what’s driving up the price, then get multiple auto insurance quotes to see if you can find a better rate.

Is a $500 or $1K deductible better for an older car?

Neither is better. A $500 deductible means less out of pocket after a covered claim, while auto insurance with a $1K deductible can lower your premium. Pick an amount you could afford without putting too much into an older car.

How much will collision insurance pay for an older car?

Collision insurance can pay up to your older car’s actual cash value if it’s totaled, minus your deductible. If the car can be repaired, it generally pays for covered repairs after your deductible, up to the car’s value.

Shopping around can help uncover better insurance prices for a car that has been on the road longer.

More FAQs