10 Best Auto Insurance Companies That Don’t Raise Rates After a Claim in 2025

#1 – Amica: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Exceptional Customer Service: Amica Mutual is renowned for its top-notch customer service, often praised for its prompt and helpful assistance in processing claims and addressing customer inquiries.
• Stable Financial Standing: With a strong financial stability rating, Amica Mutual provides peace of mind to policyholders, ensuring that they can rely on the company’s ability to fulfill its financial obligations, especially during times of need.
• Customizable Coverage Options: Amica Mutual offers a wide range of customizable coverage options, allowing policyholders to tailor their insurance plans to meet their specific needs and budgetary constraints.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: While Amica Mutual provides excellent coverage and service, some customers may find that their premiums are slightly higher compared to other insurance providers in the market.
• Limited Availability: Amica Mutual operates in a limited number of states, which could be a drawback for individuals residing outside of its coverage area who are seeking insurance options. Read more through our Amica auto insurance review.

#2 – USAA: Best for Member Focused

Pros

• Exclusive Membership Benefits: USAA offers exclusive benefits and services to its members, including discounts, specialized financial products, and personalized customer support tailored to the needs of military personnel and their families. Read more through our USAA auto insurance review.
• Outstanding Claims Handling: USAA is known for its efficient and hassle-free claims handling process, providing quick resolutions and fair settlements to policyholders in the event of accidents or other covered incidents.
• Financial Strength and Stability: With a long-standing reputation for financial strength, USAA instills confidence in its members by demonstrating stability and reliability in managing their insurance needs.

Cons

• Membership Eligibility Restrictions: USAA membership is limited to military members, veterans, and their families, excluding the general public from accessing its insurance products and services.
• Limited Coverage Options: While USAA offers quality coverage for auto insurance, its product offerings may be limited compared to other insurers, potentially restricting policyholders’ options for additional coverage types or add-ons.

#3 – State Farm: Best for Longevity Industry

Pros

• Extensive Network of Agents: State Farm boasts a vast network of local agents across the country, providing personalized service and expert guidance to policyholders, especially those who prefer face-to-face interactions when purchasing insurance.
• Variety of Discounts: State Farm offers a wide range of discounts to help policyholders save on their premiums, including multi-policy discounts, safe driving discounts, and discounts for vehicle safety features.
• Robust Online Tools and Resources: State Farm provides policyholders with access to user-friendly online tools and resources, such as mobile apps and educational materials, to manage their policies, file claims, and obtain insurance information conveniently.

Cons

• Potentially Higher Rates: While State Farm offers competitive rates for many drivers, some individuals may find that their premiums are higher compared to other insurers, particularly if they have unique risk factors or driving histories. Find out more in our State Farm auto insurance review.
• Claims Processing Times: Despite efforts to streamline the claims process, State Farm policyholders may experience longer wait times for claim resolutions during peak periods or in regions with high claim volumes.

#4 – Auto-Owners: Best for Personalized Service

Pros

• Personalized Service: Auto-Owners is known for its personalized service, with dedicated agents who work closely with policyholders to understand their unique needs and provide tailored insurance solutions.
• Strong Financial Stability: With a solid financial stability rating, Auto-Owners offers policyholders confidence in the company’s ability to fulfill its obligations and provide reliable coverage, even during challenging times. Read more through our Auto-Owners auto insurance review.
• Comprehensive Coverage Options: Auto-Owners offers a wide range of coverage options, including standard policies and specialized coverage for unique needs such as classic cars or RVs, providing policyholders with comprehensive protection.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Auto-Owners operates in a limited number of states, which may restrict access to its insurance products and services for individuals residing outside of its coverage area.
• Fewer Online Tools: While Auto-Owners provides personalized service through its network of agents, it may offer fewer online tools and resources compared to larger insurers, potentially limiting convenience for tech-savvy customers.

#5 – Erie: Best for Financial Stability

Pros

• Affordable Rates: Erie Insurance is often praised for its competitive rates, offering affordable premiums for quality coverage, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious policyholders. Read more through our Erie auto insurance review.
• Excellent Claims Service: Erie has a reputation for excellent claims service, with efficient claims processing and responsive customer support, ensuring that policyholders receive timely assistance during stressful situations.
• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Erie offers a comprehensive selection of coverage options tailored to different driver needs, including standard policies and specialized coverage for classic cars or rental vehicles.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Erie operates in a select number of states, which may limit access to its insurance products for individuals residing outside of its coverage area.
• Lack of Nationwide Recognition: While Erie offers quality coverage and service, it may not have the same level of nationwide recognition or brand awareness as larger insurers, potentially influencing consumer trust and perception in certain regions.

#6 – Nationwide: Best for Accident Forgiveness

Pros

• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Nationwide, as mentioned in our Nationwide insurance review, offers a comprehensive selection of coverage options, including standard policies and specialized coverage for unique needs such as classic cars or pet injury protection.
• Strong Financial Stability: With a solid financial strength rating, Nationwide provides policyholders with confidence in the company’s ability to meet its financial obligations and provide reliable coverage.
• Discount Opportunities: Nationwide offers various discounts, including multi-policy discounts, safe driver discounts, and discounts for vehicle safety features, helping policyholders save on their premiums.

Cons

• Mixed Customer Service Reviews: While Nationwide offers a variety of coverage options, some policyholders have reported mixed experiences with customer service, citing issues with responsiveness and claims handling.
• Higher Premiums for Some Drivers: Depending on individual factors such as driving history and location, some drivers may find that Nationwide’s premiums are higher compared to other insurers offering similar coverage.

#7 – The Hartford: Best for Extensive Coverage

Pros

• Extensive Coverage Options: The Hartford offers a wide range of coverage options tailored to different driver needs, including specialized coverage for classic cars, RVs, and high-value vehicles.
• Excellent Customer Service: The Hartford is known for its exceptional customer service, with dedicated agents who provide personalized assistance and guidance throughout the insurance process.
• Strong Financial Stability: With a strong financial stability rating, The Hartford instills confidence in policyholders, ensuring that the company can meet its financial obligations and provide reliable coverage.

Cons

• Higher Premiums for Some Drivers: While The Hartford offers comprehensive coverage options and excellent service, some drivers may find that their premiums are higher compared to other insurers.
• Limited Availability: The Hartford operates in a limited number of states, which may restrict access to its insurance products and services for individuals residing outside of its coverage area. Read more through The Hartford auto insurance review.

#8 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Customizable Policies

Pros

• Customizable Policies: Liberty Mutual offers customizable policies, allowing policyholders to tailor their coverage to meet their specific needs and budgetary constraints. For further insights, refer to our Liberty Mutual auto insurance review.
• Advanced Technology: Liberty Mutual provides policyholders with access to advanced technology tools and resources, such as mobile apps and online portals, for convenient policy management and claims processing.
• Multi-Policy Discounts: Liberty Mutual offers discounts for bundling multiple insurance policies, such as auto and home insurance, providing opportunities for policyholders to save on their premiums.

Cons

• Complex Claims Process: Some policyholders have reported challenges with Liberty Mutual’s claims process, citing issues with documentation requirements and delays in claim resolution.
• Higher Rates for Some Drivers: Depending on individual factors such as driving history and location, some drivers may find that Liberty Mutual’s premiums are higher compared to other insurers offering similar coverage.

#9 – Travelers: Best for Competitive Rates

Pros

• Competitive Rates: Our Travelers auto insurance review reveals that Travelers offers competitive rates for auto insurance, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious policyholders seeking quality coverage at affordable prices.
• Flexible Coverage Options: Travelers provides flexible coverage options, allowing policyholders to customize their policies with additional coverage types and add-ons to meet their unique needs.
• Discount Opportunities: Travelers offers various discounts, including multi-policy discounts, safe driver discounts, and discounts for vehicle safety features, helping policyholders save on their premiums.

Cons

• Mixed Customer Service Reviews: While Travelers offers competitive rates and flexible coverage options, some policyholders have reported mixed experiences with customer service, citing issues with responsiveness and claims handling.
• Limited Availability of Agents: Travelers may have a limited number of local agents available in certain areas, which could impact the accessibility of personalized assistance for policyholders who prefer face-to-face interactions.

#10 – Allstate: Best for Friendly Technology

Pros

• Innovative Technology: Allstate offers innovative technology tools such as Drivewise and QuickFoto Claim to simplify the claims process and provide personalized discounts based on driving behavior.
• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Allstate provides a comprehensive selection of coverage options, including standard policies and additional coverage for roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, and personal injury protection.
• Member Benefits: Allstate offers various member benefits, including discounts for safe driving, multi-policy discounts, and loyalty rewards, providing opportunities for policyholders to save on premiums and receive additional perks.

Cons

• Higher Premiums in Some Areas: Depending on the location and driving history, some policyholders may find that Allstate’s premiums are higher compared to other insurers offering similar coverage. Use our Allstate auto insurance review as your guide.
• Mixed Customer Service Reviews: While Allstate offers a range of coverage options and member benefits, some policyholders have reported mixed experiences with customer service, including issues with claims processing and responsiveness.

Keeping Rates Low After Filing a Claim

Drivers Finding Insurance Companies With Good Discounts

Auto Insurance Companies That Don’t Raise Your Rates Because of Claims: The Bottom Line